Consumer Reports Tests 5 More Protein Powders: 4 of 5 Pass
Clean Simple Eats, Equate, Premier Protein Powder, and Truvani tested safe for daily use; Ritual came in slightly over CR's limit
📌 Two Separate Testing Rounds
Consumer Reports tested 23 products in October 2025 and 5 chocolate powders in January 2026 — separately, with no combined #1–28 list. OWYN was an October product (88% of CR’s level of concern), and the Premier RTD was never tested — only its powder was, in January. CR published a raw microgram value for only two products across both rounds: Naked (7.7 µg) and Huel (6.3 µg) in October, plus all five January products. Everything else is reported as % of CR’s level of concern.
Last Updated: October 21, 2026
✅ Key Takeaways
- All 5 came in between 42% and 107% of CR's level of concern, lower than most products in the October round
- Clean Simple Eats had the round's lowest result (0.21 µg lead - 42% of CR's level of concern)
- Equate (Walmart) is the new budget champion ($0.60/serving, 55% of CR's level of concern)
- 4 out of 5 safe for daily use (Ritual safe for 6.5 servings/week)
- Proves manufacturers CAN make safe chocolate protein - even plant-based
What Consumer Reports Just Tested
On January 8, 2026, Consumer Reports published follow-up testing on 5 reader-requested protein powders after thousands asked: "What about MY brand?"
The results are encouraging: All 5 products tested significantly safer than the majority of powders from the October 2025 study. This proves that safe manufacturing is possible - even for chocolate-flavored and plant-based proteins that the industry claimed were "harder to keep clean."
💡 Why This Matters: Consumer Reports' October 2025 study found that more than two-thirds of the 23 products had more lead in one serving than CR's experts consider safe for a whole day - some by more than 10x. This new study shows that contamination is NOT inevitable. Companies that prioritize safety testing can make clean products.
Complete Test Results: 5 New Protein Powders Ranked
Consumer Reports tested multiple samples from 2-3 product lots of each powder to ensure results weren't skewed by outliers. All products were chocolate-flavored to control variables. Here's how they ranked:
How These Results Compare to October 2025 Testing
Consumer Reports' October 2025 study tested 23 protein powders and found that more than two-thirds had more lead per serving than CR's daily level of concern. Here's how the 5 new products stack up:
| Product | Lead (µg) | % of Limit | Overall Rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clean Simple Eats (NEW) | 0.21 | 42% | Jan 2026 round |
| Equate (NEW) | 0.27 | 55% | Jan 2026 round |
| Premier Protein Powder (NEW) | 0.38 | 77% | Jan 2026 round |
| Truvani (NEW) | 0.46 | 93% | Jan 2026 round |
| Ritual (NEW) | 0.53 | 107% | Jan 2026 round |
| OWYN Pro Elite (Oct 2025) | — | 88% | Oct 2025 round |
| Orgain Organic (Oct 2025) | — | 143% | Oct 2025 round |
CR did not combine the two rounds into one ranking. The October rows are shown for scale only.
Why These Brands Are Cleaner: Manufacturing Secrets Revealed
Consumer Reports asked all 5 companies what they do differently to achieve such low contamination levels. The answers reveal a stark divide in the industry:
🔬 Truvani: Testing Every Single Lot
Derek Halpern, Truvani Co-Founder: "I've been told routinely by my manufacturers that the volume of tests that we ask for far outstrips anyone else they've ever worked with. I just want a test result for every lot—that doesn't seem that ridiculous to me."
✅ Truvani has tested its chocolate protein powder 162 times in the last 12 months. Every lot is tested for heavy metals before sale. Ingredients that don't meet internal standards are rejected.
🌿 Ritual: Ingredient Traceability + Public Transparency
Lindsay Dahl, Ritual Chief Impact Officer: "We openly share the final place of manufacturing and the names of our suppliers for the public to see. Ingredient traceability is the best way to help reduce contaminants."
✅ Ritual publishes: Heavy metal test results for recent lots on their website, exact supplier names (Puris-brand pea protein, Cocoa Horizons cocoa), and sourcing countries. They spent 3 years testing cocoa suppliers before launching chocolate flavor.
💰 The Cost of Safety Testing
Dr. Pieter Cohen (Harvard Medical School) explained to Consumer Reports why not all companies test rigorously:
"It can be more expensive to ensure that every vat of your product is very low in lead. And without a requirement that it be that way, it's unlikely that the industry as a whole is going to move in that direction."
The problem: FDA doesn't require pre-market testing. Companies that cut corners save money. Companies that test every lot spend more but produce safer products.
⚠️ Why Most Brands Don't Test As Much
Halpern suspects many companies rely on spot-checks or certificates of analysis from ingredient suppliers instead of testing every finished lot. This is cheaper and still technically meets FDA requirements - but allows contaminated batches to slip through.
The Chocolate Protein Myth: Debunked
For years, the supplement industry claimed that chocolate-flavored proteins are inherently harder to keep clean due to cocoa contamination. These new results prove that's not an excuse:
- ✅ Clean Simple Eats chocolate: 0.21 µg lead (42% of CR's level of concern)
- ✅ Equate chocolate: 0.27 µg lead (55% of CR's level of concern)
- ✅ Premier Protein chocolate: 0.38 µg lead (77% of CR's level of concern)
- ✅ Truvani chocolate (plant-based): 0.46 µg lead (93% of CR’s level of concern)
Meanwhile, in the October 2025 study:
- 🚫 Garden of Life Sport Organic: 564% of CR’s level of concern (CR published no µg)
- 🚫 Quest Protein Shake: 161% of CR’s level of concern (CR published no µg)
- 🚫 Vega Premium Sport: 185% of CR’s level of concern (CR published no µg)
💡 The Takeaway: Chocolate contamination is NOT inevitable. Companies that source carefully and test rigorously can make chocolate protein with minimal lead.
Plant-Based Protein: Finally Two Safe Options
The October 2025 study was devastating for plant-based protein users: 9 of the 10 plant-based products came in above CR's level of concern. OWYN Pro Elite, a ready-to-drink shake at 88%, was the only one under it.
Now there are TWO verified-safe plant proteins:
🥇 OWYN Pro Elite
Safe for daily use. The original safe plant protein champion from October 2025 testing.
Read OWYN Analysis →🥈 Truvani Plant-Based
Safe for daily use. NEW January 2026. Slightly higher than OWYN (93% vs 88%), but Truvani tests every production lot.
Buy Truvani →If you're vegan or plant-based, you now have TWO safe options instead of one. Both are pea protein-based and safe for daily consumption.
How the 5 New Products Compare to Everything CR Has Tested
Consumer Reports ran two separate rounds — October 2025 (23 products) and January 2026 (5 reader-requested powders) — and did not combine them into one ranked list. Here's the cleanest 5 from the October round, plus all 5 from January, so you can see where the new results land on the same 0.5 µg/day scale:
| Round | Product | Lead (µg) | % of CR's Level of Concern | Safety |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 2025 #1 | MuscleTech 100% Mass Gainer | Not Detected | 0% | ✅ Safe |
| Oct 2025 #2 | Dymatize Super Mass Gainer | — | 25% | ✅ Safe |
| Oct 2025 #3 | Momentous Whey Isolate | — | 30% | ✅ Safe |
| Oct 2025 #4 | BSN Syntha-6 | — | 46% | ✅ Safe |
| Oct 2025 #5 | Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard | — | 56% | ✅ Safe |
| Jan 2026 | 🆕 Clean Simple Eats Chocolate | 0.21 | 42% | ✅ Safe |
| Jan 2026 | 🆕 Equate Whey Chocolate | 0.27 | 55% | ✅ Safe |
| Jan 2026 | 🆕 Premier Protein Powder Chocolate | 0.38 | 77% | ✅ Safe |
| Jan 2026 | 🆕 Truvani Plant-Based Chocolate | 0.46 | 93% | ✅ Safe |
| Jan 2026 | 🆕 Ritual Essential Protein Chocolate | 0.53 | 107% | ⚠️ Caution |
| Oct 2025 | [The other 18 October 2025 products, ranked by lead level — see complete rankings] | |||
What This Means for You
✅ Action Steps
If You're Using One of These 5 New Brands:
Good news. CR rated Clean Simple Eats, Equate, Premier Protein powder and Truvani better for daily use, and Ritual okay for up to 6.5 servings a week.
If You're Using a Brand NOT Tested:
Heavy metal content is unknown. Consumer Reports has tested 23 products (October 2025) and 5 more (January 2026). If your brand wasn't included, there's no public testing data. Consider switching to a verified-safe option or requesting third-party testing from the manufacturer.
If You're Using a Brand That Failed October Testing:
Switch immediately. These new results prove that safe alternatives exist at every price point. There's no reason to continue consuming contaminated protein.
Check Your Brand's Safety →FDA Still Has No Lead Limits for Protein Powders
Despite these encouraging results, there are still no federal limits for heavy metals in protein powders. The FDA doesn't require pre-market testing, and companies are left to self-regulate.
Consumer Reports' petition calling for strict FDA standards has garnered over 43,000 signatures since October 2025.
"The FDA is still lacking enforceable lead limits for protein powders and dietary supplements. Having these standards in place would push the industry to consistently make products with lower levels of lead, which our test results certainly demonstrate is possible for companies to do."
— Brian Ronholm, Consumer Reports Director of Food Policy
Ritual's CEO, Katerina Schneider, went further - calling on Congress to "empower the FDA to establish health-protective limits for heavy metals in supplements and protein powder."
📢 Want to Help?
Sign Consumer Reports' petition: action.consumerreports.org/protein_powder
Our Recommendations: Updated Top 10 Safe Protein Powders (2026)
Based on both Consumer Reports rounds, here are our updated top recommendations:
🏆 Best Overall Safe Protein Powders
- MuscleTech 100% Mass Gainer - Lead not detected (lowest in the October round)
- Clean Simple Eats Chocolate - 0.21 µg (NEW, best chocolate)
- Equate Whey Chocolate - 0.27 µg (NEW, best budget at ~$0.60/serv)
- Premier Protein Powder Chocolate - 0.38 µg (NEW; powder only, the RTD was never tested)
- Truvani Plant-Based Chocolate - 0.46 µg (NEW, 2nd safe plant protein)
- Dymatize Super Mass Gainer - Lead 25% of CR’s level of concern
- Momentous Whey Isolate - Lead 30% of CR’s level of concern, NSF Certified
- Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard - Lead 56% of CR’s level of concern
- Body Fortress - non-detectable (Clean Label Project, not Consumer Reports tested), $0.67/serving
- OWYN Pro Elite - 88% of concern (still the top plant-based pick from October, CR #7 overall)
See our complete Best Protein Powders 2025 buying guide for detailed analysis.
Frequently Asked Questions
❓ Are all chocolate protein powders contaminated?
No. These new results prove chocolate protein CAN be made safely. Clean Simple Eats, Equate, Premier Protein Powder, and Truvani all have chocolate flavors with minimal lead (42-93% of CR's level of concern). The industry's excuse that "chocolate is inherently contaminated" is debunked.
❓ Which brand is the safest chocolate protein now?
Clean Simple Eats Chocolate Brownie Batter at 0.21 µg lead (42% of CR's level of concern), the lowest result in CR's January round.
❓ Is Premier Protein powder safer than the RTD shake?
Yes. Premier Protein's powder tested at 0.38 µg (77% of CR's level of concern) in January 2026. CR rated it better for daily use. CR has never tested the bottled RTD shakes, so there's no CR result to compare them against.
❓ What about Equate vs Body Fortress for budget protein?
Equate is now the safer budget choice. Equate tested at 0.27 µg (55% of CR's level of concern) vs Body Fortress, which CR hasn't tested but whose Super Advanced Whey (Vanilla) is on Clean Label Project's Clean Sixteen list. Equate is also slightly cheaper at ~$0.60/serving vs $0.67. Both are excellent budget options.
❓ Is Truvani worth the premium price vs OWYN?
OWYN is slightly lower. Truvani tested at 0.46 µg (93% of CR's level of concern) in January. OWYN Pro Elite measured 88% in October. Both were cleared for daily use. Truvani tests every production lot (162 tests in 12 months), and it's a powder while OWYN Pro Elite is a ready-to-drink shake, so format may decide it for you.
❓ Why is Ritual slightly over the limit but still recommended?
Context matters. Ritual tested at 107% of CR's level of concern (0.53 µg), just over the line. CR's 0.5 µg/day benchmark is deliberately conservative, and CR rates Ritual okay for up to 6.5 servings per week (nearly daily) and demonstrates strong transparency by publishing test results publicly.
❓ Should I switch from my current brand to one of these?
If your brand wasn't tested by Consumer Reports, yes. With 28 products tested across CR's two separate rounds, you have verified-safe options at every price point ($0.60 to $2.50/serving). There's no reason to use an untested brand when safe alternatives exist. Use our Brand Safety Checker to verify your current protein.
Related Articles
Not Sure Which Safe Protein to Choose?
Get personalized recommendations based on your goals, budget, and dietary preferences
Take Free Safety Quiz →Sources:
- Consumer Reports: "These 5 Protein Powders Had Low Levels of Lead" (January 8, 2026)
- Consumer Reports: Heavy metal testing methodology (January 2026)
- Consumer Reports: "Protein Powders and Shakes Contain High Levels of Lead" (October 2025)
- Interviews with Truvani co-founder Derek Halpern and Ritual Chief Impact Officer Lindsay Dahl
Last Updated: October 21, 2026