Premier Protein vs Muscle Milk: Which RTD Shake is Safer? (2025 Consumer Reports Testing)
Consumer Reports tested both Premier Protein and Muscle Milk in October 2025. The results are definitive: Premier Protein ranked #6 with 0.59 µg lead per serving (safe for daily use). Muscle Milk ranked #17 with 1.25 µg lead per serving (NOT safe for daily use). Premier has 2.1x LESS lead, more protein, fewer calories, and costs less per serving.
This isn't a close call. If you're choosing between these two brands, the data overwhelmingly supports Premier Protein. This article breaks down every aspect - safety, nutrition, taste, price, availability - so you can make an informed decision.
⚖️ The Head-to-Head Matchup
Premier Protein
#6 Safest
0.59 µg lead
Muscle Milk
#17 Safest
1.25 µg lead
🏆 WINNER: PREMIER PROTEIN
Premier Protein beats Muscle Milk in 8 out of 9 categories:
✅ Safety (2.1x less lead) | ✅ Price ($0.50 cheaper) | ✅ Protein (30g vs 25g)
✅ Calories (160 vs 230) | ✅ Sugar (1g vs 3g) | ✅ Availability
✅ Daily use safety | ✅ Value per gram of protein
Jump to Section:
Safety Comparison: Consumer Reports Lead Testing Results
This is the most important category, and it's not close. Consumer Reports tested both products for heavy metal contamination in October 2025.
The Test Results:
| Metric | Premier Protein | Muscle Milk | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consumer Reports Rank | #6 out of 23 | #17 out of 23 | ✅ Premier |
| Lead per serving | 0.59 µg | 1.25 µg | ✅ Premier (2.1x less) |
| % Over safe limit | 18% over | 150% over | ✅ Premier |
| Safe for daily use? | ✅ YES (1 serving/day) | ❌ NO | ✅ Premier |
| Maximum safe frequency | Daily | Every 2-3 days | ✅ Premier |
✅ Premier Protein: #6 Ranked Safest
Lead Level: 0.59 µg per 11 oz serving
Safety Rating: "Better" for daily consumption (Consumer Reports)
Why It's Safe:
- ✅ Only 18% over California's safe limit (minimal)
- ✅ Rated safe for 1 serving per day
- ✅ 11 ranks SAFER than Muscle Milk
- ✅ Verified by independent third-party testing
Annual Lead Exposure (Daily Use):
0.59 µg/day × 365 days = 215 µg/year
Still elevated but within acceptable range for daily consumption according to Consumer Reports methodology.
⚠️ Muscle Milk: #17 Ranked
Lead Level: 1.25 µg per 14 oz serving
Safety Rating: "Concerning" for daily consumption
Why It's Problematic:
- ❌ 150% over California's safe limit
- ❌ NOT rated safe for daily consumption
- ❌ 2.1x MORE lead than Premier Protein
- ❌ Bottom third of tested products
Annual Lead Exposure (Daily Use):
1.25 µg/day × 365 days = 456 µg/year
Over double Premier's exposure. NOT recommended for daily consumption by Consumer Reports.
The Safety Verdict: Premier Protein exposes you to 2.1x LESS lead than Muscle Milk. Over one year of daily consumption, that's the difference between 215 µg (Premier) vs 456 µg (Muscle Milk) - an extra 241 µg of lead accumulating in your body. Lead doesn't leave - it stays in your bones and organs for decades. Choose Premier if you're consuming daily.
Nutrition Comparison: Protein, Calories, Macros
Beyond safety, how do these shakes compare nutritionally? Premier Protein dominates here too.
Complete Nutrition Breakdown:
| Nutrient (per serving) | Premier Protein (11 oz) | Muscle Milk (14 oz) | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protein | 30g | 25g | ✅ Premier (+5g) |
| Calories | 160 | 230 | ✅ Premier (-70 cal) |
| Fat | 3g | 9g | ✅ Premier (-6g) |
| Carbs | 5g | 8g | ✅ Premier (-3g) |
| Sugar | 1g | 3g | ✅ Premier (-2g) |
| Protein per calorie | 0.188g/cal | 0.109g/cal | ✅ Premier (72% better) |
| Serving size | 11 oz (smaller bottle) | 14 oz (larger bottle) | ⚖️ Muscle Milk (if size matters) |
What This Means for Different Goals:
✅ Premier Protein Wins For:
- Weight loss / cutting: 70 fewer calories + more protein = better body composition
- Protein efficiency: 30g protein in 160 calories vs 25g in 230 calories
- Low-carb diets: Only 5g carbs (1g sugar) vs 8g carbs (3g sugar)
- Daily protein supplementation: Lean profile perfect for hitting protein targets without excess calories
- Post-workout recovery: More protein, less fat = faster absorption
⚖️ Muscle Milk Might Work For:
- Bulking: Extra 70 calories + 6g fat = easier caloric surplus (but still not worth the 2.1x lead exposure)
- Meal replacement: Higher calories = more satiating (but Premier + a banana = better nutrition)
- Prefer larger serving: 14 oz feels more substantial than 11 oz (psychological, not nutritional)
Reality Check: Even for bulking, Muscle Milk's advantages are marginal and NOT worth 2.1x the lead exposure. Add a banana or handful of nuts to Premier Protein if you need extra calories. Don't poison yourself for 70 calories.
Taste & Texture Comparison
This is subjective, but here's the consensus from thousands of consumer reviews:
The Taste Profile:
🥤 Premier Protein
Taste: Sweet, dessert-like, artificial sweetener aftertaste (sucralose)
Texture: Thin, milk-like consistency, smooth
Popular Flavors: Café Latte (best seller), Chocolate, Vanilla, Caramel
Consumer Consensus: "Tastes like chocolate milk with artificial sweetener. Not amazing, but perfectly drinkable and consistent across batches."
Pros:
- ✅ Consistent taste batch-to-batch
- ✅ Mixes well (no clumping)
- ✅ Café Latte flavor is unique/popular
Cons:
- ❌ Artificial sweetener aftertaste
- ❌ Thin consistency (some prefer thicker)
- ❌ Very sweet (can be cloying)
🥤 Muscle Milk
Taste: Richer, creamier, more "milkshake-like," less artificial
Texture: Thick, creamy, more substantial mouthfeel
Popular Flavors: Chocolate, Vanilla Crème, Cookies & Crème
Consumer Consensus: "Tastes more like real chocolate milk. Thicker and more satisfying texture. Less artificial tasting than Premier."
Pros:
- ✅ Creamier, more indulgent taste
- ✅ Less artificial sweetener taste
- ✅ Thicker texture feels more filling
Cons:
- ❌ Inconsistent between batches
- ❌ Some flavors have chalky aftertaste
- ❌ Can be too thick for some
The Taste Verdict:
Winner: Muscle Milk (Barely)
Muscle Milk has a slight edge in taste - it's creamier, richer, and less artificial-tasting than Premier. Many consumers prefer Muscle Milk's flavor.
BUT... Taste is the ONLY category where Muscle Milk wins. And it's not worth 2.1x the lead exposure. If Premier's taste bothers you, try different flavors (Café Latte is often preferred over Chocolate) or choose a safer brand entirely (Dymatize ISO100, Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard).
Price & Value Comparison
Premier Protein is cheaper and delivers better value per gram of protein:
Price Breakdown (Retail Prices):
| Store | Premier Protein (12-pack) | Muscle Milk (12-pack) | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Costco | $18-20 ($1.50-1.67/shake) | $24-26 ($2.00-2.17/shake) | Premier $0.50 cheaper |
| Amazon | $22-24 ($1.83-2.00/shake) | $28-30 ($2.33-2.50/shake) | Premier $0.50 cheaper |
| Walmart | $20-22 ($1.67-1.83/shake) | $26-28 ($2.17-2.33/shake) | Premier $0.50 cheaper |
| Gas Station (single) | $3.00-3.50 | $2.50-3.00 | Muscle Milk $0.50 cheaper |
Value Per Gram of Protein:
Premier Protein Value:
- Price per shake: $1.50-2.00 (Costco/bulk pricing)
- Protein per shake: 30g
- Cost per 10g protein: $0.50-0.67
- Annual cost (daily): $548-730/year
Muscle Milk Value:
- Price per shake: $2.00-2.50 (Costco/bulk pricing)
- Protein per shake: 25g
- Cost per 10g protein: $0.80-1.00
- Annual cost (daily): $730-913/year
Annual Cost Comparison (Daily Consumption):
| Scenario | Premier Protein | Muscle Milk | Annual Savings (Premier) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 shake/day for 1 year | $548-730 | $730-913 | $182-183 saved |
| 2 shakes/day for 1 year | $1,096-1,460 | $1,460-1,825 | $364-365 saved |
| 3x per week for 1 year | $234-312 | $312-390 | $78 saved |
The Price Verdict: Premier Protein is cheaper per shake ($0.50 less), delivers more protein per serving (30g vs 25g), AND has better value per gram of protein. Over one year of daily consumption, you save $180+ while exposing yourself to 2.1x LESS lead. This is a no-brainer.
Availability & Convenience Comparison
Both brands are widely available, but distribution differs:
Where You Can Buy Each Brand:
| Retail Channel | Premier Protein | Muscle Milk | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Costco | ✅ Yes (18-pack) | ✅ Yes (12-pack) | Tie (both available) |
| Walmart | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | Tie |
| Target | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | Tie |
| Amazon | ✅ Yes (Subscribe & Save) | ✅ Yes | Tie |
| Gas Stations | ❌ Rarely | ✅ Yes (everywhere) | Muscle Milk |
| 7-Eleven | ❌ No | ✅ Yes | Muscle Milk |
| Gym Vending/Coolers | ⚠️ Sometimes | ✅ Usually | Muscle Milk |
| Grocery Stores | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | Tie |
The Convenience Trade-Off:
Muscle Milk's ONLY Real Advantage: Gas Station Availability
If you're on a road trip, at the airport, or need protein RIGHT NOW and the only option is a gas station, Muscle Milk will be there. Premier Protein won't.
But here's the reality check:
- ✅ You can order Premier on Amazon with same-day delivery in most cities
- ✅ You can stock up at Costco once per month (18-pack for $18-20)
- ✅ You can keep a few Premier shakes in your car, gym bag, office
- ✅ Gas station convenience isn't worth 2.1x the lead exposure
Bottom Line: If you're consuming protein shakes regularly (3+ times per week), you should be buying in bulk from Costco/Amazon/Walmart anyway. Gas station availability is only relevant for emergency situations - not daily consumption habits.
Category-by-Category Scorecard: Who Wins?
Let's tally up every category and crown a definitive winner:
| Category | Premier Protein | Muscle Milk | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Safety (Lead Level) | 0.59 µg (#6 ranked) | 1.25 µg (#17 ranked) | ✅ Premier (2.1x safer) |
| 2. Protein Content | 30g | 25g | ✅ Premier (+5g) |
| 3. Calories | 160 | 230 | ✅ Premier (-70 cal) |
| 4. Fat | 3g | 9g | ✅ Premier (-6g) |
| 5. Sugar | 1g | 3g | ✅ Premier (-2g) |
| 6. Price | $1.50-2.00/shake | $2.00-2.50/shake | ✅ Premier ($0.50 cheaper) |
| 7. Value ($/10g protein) | $0.50-0.67 | $0.80-1.00 | ✅ Premier (better value) |
| 8. Daily Use Safety | ✅ Safe for daily | ❌ Not safe for daily | ✅ Premier |
| 9. Taste | Good, but artificial | Better, creamier | ⚠️ Muscle Milk (slight edge) |
| 10. Gas Station Availability | ❌ Rarely | ✅ Everywhere | ⚠️ Muscle Milk |
🏆 FINAL SCORE
Premier Protein
8
Categories Won
Muscle Milk
2
Categories Won
Premier Protein dominates Muscle Milk in every category that matters:
Safety, Nutrition, Price, and Daily Use Suitability
Premier vs Muscle Milk FAQ
Q: Is Premier Protein actually safer, or is the difference negligible?
A: The difference is SIGNIFICANT. Premier has 0.59 µg lead vs Muscle Milk's 1.25 µg - that's 2.1x less lead. Over one year of daily consumption, that's 215 µg (Premier) vs 456 µg (Muscle Milk) - an extra 241 µg of lead accumulating in your body. Lead bioaccumulates in bones and organs with no natural elimination pathway. Consumer Reports rated Premier safe for daily use and Muscle Milk NOT safe for daily use. This isn't negligible.
Q: Can I just drink Muscle Milk less frequently to make it safe?
A: Yes, but why? Muscle Milk is safe at once every 2-3 days. But Premier is safe for DAILY use, costs LESS, and has MORE protein. If you're only consuming protein shakes 2-3 times per week, either option works. But if you're consuming daily or want the flexibility to consume daily, Premier is the obvious choice. There's no scenario where Muscle Milk's marginal taste advantage justifies 2.1x the lead exposure.
Q: I've been drinking Muscle Milk daily for years. Should I be worried?
A: Not "worried" in the sense of immediate danger, but you should switch to Premier going forward. If you've consumed Muscle Milk daily for multiple years, you've accumulated significant lead (456 µg/year adds up). Consider requesting blood lead testing from your doctor (simple blood test). Then switch to Premier immediately to stop further accumulation. The good news: stopping exposure prevents additional buildup, and blood lead levels drop over time (though bone/organ lead persists).
Q: Does Premier Protein taste as good as Muscle Milk?
A: Most consumers say Muscle Milk tastes slightly better - it's creamier and less artificial. Premier has a thinner consistency and more artificial sweetener taste. BUT: (1) Taste is subjective, (2) Many people prefer Premier's Café Latte flavor, (3) You adjust to Premier's taste after a few days. The taste difference is NOT worth 2.1x the lead exposure. Try Premier's different flavors - Café Latte, Caramel, and Vanilla are often preferred over Chocolate.
Q: What if I can only buy Muscle Milk at gas stations when traveling?
A: Occasional Muscle Milk consumption (once per week or less) is acceptable. The danger is DAILY consumption. If you're on a road trip and Muscle Milk is your only option, it's fine for a few days. But for regular consumption (3+ times per week), order Premier on Amazon or stock up at Costco. Don't make gas station convenience your default - plan ahead and keep Premier in your car/gym bag.
Q: Are there even safer options than Premier Protein?
A: Yes! If you want the absolute safest options, choose protein powders (not RTD shakes): MuscleTech 100% Mass Gainer (#1 - lead not detected), Dymatize ISO100 (#2 - below detection), or Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard (#5 - below detection). These require mixing but have zero detectable lead. If you need RTD convenience, Premier (#6) is your best option among ready-to-drink shakes.
Q: Does Premier Protein have any downsides?
A: Minor ones: (1) Artificial sweetener taste (sucralose) bothers some people, (2) Thinner consistency than Muscle Milk, (3) Very sweet (can be cloying). But these are taste preferences, not health concerns. Premier's 0.59 µg lead is still 18% over California's safe limit - it's not perfect, but it's 2.1x safer than Muscle Milk and the best RTD option tested by Consumer Reports.
Q: What about other Muscle Milk products (powder, Pro, Zero Sugar)?
A: Consumer Reports only tested Muscle Milk Genuine RTD shake (chocolate, 14 oz). Other Muscle Milk products (powder, Muscle Milk Pro, Zero Sugar) were NOT tested. They likely have similar contamination levels since they use similar protein sources, but we can't confirm without independent testing. If you want verified-safe options, choose products that HAVE been tested (Premier for RTD, MuscleTech/Dymatize/ON for powder).
Q: Is Muscle Milk Zero Sugar safer than regular Muscle Milk?
A: Unknown - it wasn't tested. "Zero Sugar" refers to carbohydrate content, not heavy metal contamination. Lead contamination comes from the protein source (whey), not the sweetener. Muscle Milk Zero Sugar likely has similar lead levels to regular Muscle Milk since they use the same whey protein base. Without testing, we're speculating. Choose Premier (tested safe) instead.
Q: Can I mix Premier and Muscle Milk to "average out" the lead exposure?
A: Technically yes, but why? If you alternate Premier (0.59 µg) and Muscle Milk (1.25 µg), your average exposure is 0.92 µg/day. But this is worse than just using Premier daily (0.59 µg). There's no benefit to mixing them - just use Premier exclusively. The only reason to keep Muscle Milk around is for emergency situations when Premier isn't available.
The Final Verdict: Premier Protein Wins Decisively
This comparison isn't close. Premier Protein beats Muscle Milk in 8 out of 10 categories.
✅ Why Premier Protein is the Clear Winner:
- 2.1x safer: 0.59 µg lead vs 1.25 µg (241 µg less exposure per year)
- $180+ cheaper annually: $1.50-2.00/shake vs $2.00-2.50/shake
- More protein: 30g vs 25g (+5g per serving)
- Fewer calories: 160 vs 230 (-70 calories for weight loss)
- Better macros: Less fat, less sugar, less carbs
- Safe for daily use: Consumer Reports verified
- Better value: More protein per dollar
- Widely available: Costco, Walmart, Amazon (bulk pricing)
⚠️ Muscle Milk's ONLY Advantages:
- Slightly better taste: Creamier, less artificial (subjective, marginal)
- Gas station availability: Convenient for emergencies only
These two advantages DO NOT justify 2.1x the lead exposure, higher price, and inferior nutrition profile.
Bottom Line: If you're choosing between Premier Protein and Muscle Milk, choose Premier. It's safer, cheaper, and more nutritious. The ONLY reason to choose Muscle Milk is if you're stuck at a gas station with no other options - and even then, it's a temporary compromise, not a daily habit.
✅ Make the Switch to Premier Protein Today
#6 ranked safest by Consumer Reports. 2.1x LESS lead than Muscle Milk. 30g protein. 160 calories. Cheaper per serving. Safe for daily use.
Buy Premier Protein (12-Pack) on Amazon →0.59 µg lead (verified safe) | Best-selling RTD shake | Subscribe & Save for 15% off
Sources:
- Consumer Reports: "Heavy Metals in Protein Powders and Shakes" (October 14, 2025)
- Retail pricing data: Costco, Amazon, Walmart (November-December 2025)
- Nutrition data: Premier Protein and Muscle Milk product labels
Last Updated: December 10, 2025
Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links to Amazon. When you purchase through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products with verified safety testing. Rankings based solely on independent Consumer Reports testing. Learn more.